Simplistik Roofing - What to Look For in a Roof When Buying a Home

What to Look for in a Roof When Buying a Home

How To'sBy Dustin MatosUpdated 6 min read

When you’re touring homes, it’s easy to focus on the kitchen, the bedrooms and the neighborhood. The roof is easy to overlook, but it’s one of the most expensive parts of a house to replace, and a roof near the end of its life can turn into a five-figure surprise within a few years of moving in.

The good news is that you don’t need to climb a ladder to learn a lot about a roof. Here’s what to look for, which documents to ask for, and how to use what you find when you negotiate.

Key takeaways

  • Find out the roof’s age and ask for receipts, permits and any transferable warranty.
  • Look for curling, missing or bare shingles from the ground, and for stains or daylight in the attic.
  • A general home inspection is a starting point. A roofing professional can give you a closer look and a repair or replacement estimate.
  • Roof problems aren’t always deal-breakers. They’re often a reason to negotiate a repair, a credit or a lower price.

Start with the roof’s age and history

The first question to ask is how old the roof is. Most asphalt shingle roofs last about 20 to 30 years, depending on the product, the installation and how well the attic is ventilated. A roof that’s 18 or 20 years old may still have life left, but you should budget for its replacement.

Ask the sellers or their agent for:

  • The year the roof was installed, and the name of the contractor.
  • Invoices, building permits and any inspection reports.
  • Manufacturer and workmanship warranties, and whether they transfer to a new owner.
  • A history of leaks, repairs or insurance claims.

In Pennsylvania and New Jersey, sellers generally provide a property disclosure statement that includes questions about the roof, such as its age and any leaks. Read that section carefully and ask follow-up questions about anything that’s unclear.

Know the roofing material

Different materials age differently. Architectural asphalt shingles are the most common in our area and typically last 20 to 30 years. Older three-tab shingles tend to wear out sooner. Metal, slate and tile can last much longer but are more expensive to repair. The material also affects homeowners insurance, and some insurers ask about the age and type of roof when writing a policy. For a deeper comparison, see our guide on how to choose the right roof type.

What to look for from the outside

Walk around the house and look at every side of the roof. Binoculars help. Watch for:

  • Curling, cupping or cracked shingles, which are signs of age and heat damage.
  • Missing shingles or exposed nails, often from wind.
  • Bald spots where the shingles have lost their protective granules.
  • Moss, algae or heavy streaking, especially on shaded slopes.
  • A sagging or wavy roofline, which can mean water damage to the decking or problems with the framing.
  • Rust on metal roofing, flashing or vents.
  • Patched areas with mismatched shingles, which suggest past repairs.
  • More than one layer of shingles at the edges. A second layer installed over the first makes the next replacement more expensive.

What to look for inside and in the attic

Some of the most telling signs of roof trouble are inside the house. Look at ceilings, especially on the top floor and near exterior walls, for brown or yellow water stains, peeling paint or fresh patches of paint that might be covering something.

If you can get into the attic, look for:

  • Water stains, dark spots or rot on the rafters and the underside of the roof deck.
  • Mold, mildew or a musty smell.
  • Damp, compressed or stained insulation.
  • Daylight coming through the roof boards. That’s a definite red flag.
  • Frost or condensation on the roof deck in winter, which points to poor ventilation.

Check the gutters, flashing and ventilation

Gutters and downspouts

Gutters should be firmly attached, free of debris and directing water away from the foundation. Large amounts of shingle granules in the gutters or at the bottom of downspouts suggest the shingles are near the end of their life.

Flashing

Flashing is the metal that seals the joints around chimneys, vents, skylights, walls and valleys. It’s one of the most common sources of leaks. Look for bent, lifted or rusted flashing and cracked or missing sealant.

Ventilation

A properly ventilated attic keeps the roof deck cool and dry, reduces ice dams in winter and helps shingles last. Look for soffit vents under the eaves and ridge or roof vents near the top. A very hot or humid attic is a warning sign.

Home inspection vs. a roof inspection

A general home inspection is essential, but it’s a broad look at the whole house. Home inspectors often evaluate the roof from the ground, a ladder or a drone, and may recommend a closer look by a roofing contractor if they see anything concerning.

A roofing professional can tell you how much life the roof likely has left, whether problems can be repaired, and what a repair or replacement would cost. That estimate is valuable when you’re deciding how to proceed with the purchase.

What to do if the roof needs work

A roof in less-than-perfect condition isn’t automatically a deal-breaker. It’s information you can use. Depending on what you find and the terms of your agreement, common options include:

  • Asking the seller to make specific repairs before closing, by a licensed and insured contractor.
  • Requesting a credit at closing so you can choose your own contractor afterward.
  • Negotiating a lower purchase price that reflects the cost of a replacement.
  • Walking away if the problems are severe and your agreement allows it.

Your real estate agent can advise you on what’s typical and what your agreement of sale allows. Having a written estimate from a roofer makes any of these conversations easier.

Your roof checklist when buying a home

Check What you want to see
Age Documented install date, ideally with receipts and permits
Warranty Manufacturer and workmanship warranties that transfer to you
Shingles Flat, intact shingles with granules still in place
Roofline Straight ridge and flat roof planes, no sagging
Flashing Tight, sealed and rust-free around chimneys, vents and walls
Attic Dry wood and insulation, no daylight, no musty smell
Gutters Secure, clear and draining away from the house
Ceilings No stains, bubbling paint or suspicious fresh patches

Frequently asked questions

How can I tell how old a roof is if the seller doesn’t know?

Check public permit records with the township or borough, ask neighbors when their roofs were done, and have a roofer evaluate the shingles. An experienced roofer can usually estimate the age within a few years.

Should I buy a house that needs a new roof?

Many buyers do. The key is knowing the cost in advance and factoring it into your offer, your negotiations or your budget for the first few years.

Will an old roof affect my homeowners insurance?

It can. Some insurers ask about the age and condition of the roof, and an older roof may affect coverage or premiums. Talk to your insurance agent early in the buying process.

Can Simplistik Roofing inspect a roof before I buy?

Yes. We offer free roof inspections and estimates in the Lehigh Valley, the Poconos and western New Jersey, so you can make your decision with real numbers.

Look up before you buy

A roof plays a big role in protecting a home and its value. When you’re house-hunting, take a few minutes to look up, ask for the roof’s history and get a professional opinion before you commit. It could save you from an unwelcome surprise a few years down the road, and it gives you leverage while you still have it.

Free inspection & estimate

Get a straight answer about your roof

Tell us a little about your home and a Simplistik Roofing specialist will set up a time to inspect your roof and walk you through your options, at no cost and with no pressure.

  • Free inspections & estimates
  • Lifetime warranty on all products
  • 0% interest financing available
  • Customer satisfaction guaranteed

Request an Estimate

Takes less than a minute

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name(Required)

5.0 from 190+ Google reviews

Get Your Free Estimate

Takes less than a minute

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name(Required)